placeholder.png

Brief response to Ashton and colleagues regarding Fractionating Human Intelligence

Ashton and colleagues concede in their response (Ashton, Lee, & Visser, 2014), that neuroimaging methods provide a relatively unambiguous measure of the levels to which cognitive tasks co-recruit different functional brain networks (task mixing). It is also evident from their response that they now accept that task mixing differs from the blended models of the classic literature. However, they still have not grasped how the neuroimaging data can help to constrain models of the neural basis of higher order ‘g’. Specifically, they claim that our analyses are invalid as we assume that functional networks have uncorrelated capacities. They use the simple analogy of a set of exercises that recruit multiple muscle groups to varying extents and highlight the fact that individual differences in strength may correlate across muscle groups. Contrary to their claim, we did not assume in the original article (Hampshire, Highfield …

Authors
A Hampshire, B Parkin, R Highfield, AM Owen – Personality and Individual Differences, 2014
Publication date
2014/4/1
Source
Personality and Individual Differences
Volume
60
Issue
—
Pages
16-17
Publisher
Pergamon
Total citations
Cited by 2

Table of Contents

08dbc96d-325a-451c-84f4-bef183341e85

Before you go — get the Oxford Health Bulletin

Practical insights, new research and case studies on prevention and public health — straight to your inbox, about once a month. No spam, unsubscribe any time.